The Handmaids Tale Essay, Research Paper
Many readers are surprised to hear AtwoodТs novel labeled science fiction, but it belongs squarely in the long tradition of near-future dystopias which has made up a large part of SF since the early50s. SF need not involve technological innovation: it has been a long-standing principle that social change can provide the basis for SF just as well as technical change. The HandmaidТs Tale is partly an extrapolation of Rachel CarsonТs Silent Spring, attempting to imagine what kind of values might evolve if environmental pollution rendered most of the human race sterile. It is also the product of debates within the feminist movement in the 70s and early 80s. Atwood has been very much a part of that movement, but she has never been a mere mouthpiece for any group, always insisting on her individual perspectives. The defeat of the Equal Rights Amendment, the rise of the religious right, the election of Ronald Reagan, and many sorts of backlash (mostly hugely misinformed) against the womenТs movement led writers like Atwood to fear that the antifeminist tide could not only prevent further gains for women, but turn back the clock. Dystopias are a kind of thought experiment which isolates certain social trends and exaggerates them to make clear their most negative qualities. They are rarely intended as realistic predictions of a probable future, and it is pointless to criticize them on the grounds of implausibility. Atwood here examines some of the traditional attitudes that are embedded in the thinking of the religious right and which she finds particularly threatening.
But another social controversy also underlies this novel. During the early 80s a debate raged (and continues to rage, on a lower level) about feminist attitudes toward sexuality and pornography in particular. Outspoken feminists have taken all kinds of positions: that all erotica depicting women as sexual objects is demeaning, that pornography was bad though erotica can be good, that although most pornography is demeaning the protection of civil liberties is a greater good which requires the toleration of freedom for pornographers, however distasteful, even that such a thing as feminist pornography can and should be created.
The sub-theme of this tangled debate which seems to have particularly interested and alarmed Atwood is the tendency of some feminist anti-porn groups to ally themselves with religious anti-porn zealots who oppose the feminists on almost every other issue. The language of Уprotection of womenФ could slip from a demand for more freedom into a retreat from freedom, to a kind of neo-Victorianism. After all, it was the need to protect УgoodФ women from sex that justified all manner of repression in the 19th century, including confining them to the home, barring them from participating in the arts, and voting. Contemporary Islamic women sometimes argue that assuming the veil and traditional all-enveloping clothing is aimed at dealing with sexual harassment and sexual objectification. The language is feminist, but the result can be deeply patriarchal, as in this novel.
Without some sense of the varying agendas of mid-20th-century feminists and the debates among those agendas this novel will not make much sense. Women who participated in the movement from the late sixties and early seventies responded to this novel strongly, often finding it extremely alarming. Younger women lacking the same background often found it baffling. Ask yourself as you read not whether events such as it depict s are likely to take place, but whether the attitudes and values it conveys are present in todayТs society.
AtwoodТs strong point is satire, often hilarious, often very pointed. Humor is in short supply in this novel, but it is a satire nonetheless. AtwoodТs love for language play (apparent in the anagram of her name she uses for her private business УO. W. ToadФ) is a major feature of the protagonist of this novel. Her jokes are dark and bitter, but they are pervasive.
There are numerous biblical references in the following notes. You shouldprovide yourself with a Bible, preferably a King James Version, which is whatAtwood uses most of the time. Or use a great searchable http://tuna.uchicago.edu/homes/BIBLES.html.reductio ad absurdum, a theoretical exercise designed to stimulate thought about social issues ratherthan a realistic portrait of a probable future by comparing herself to JonathanSwift, who in A Modest Proposal highlighted the hard-heartednessof the English in allowing the Irish masses to starve by satirically proposingthat they should be encouraged to eat their own children. It is not so obviouswhat the application of the third epigraph is to this novel. It seems to saythat no one needs to forbid what is undesirable. Can you interpret it anyfurther?
Section I: Night
Read the first sentence. What can you tell about the period just from this sentence? People generally sleep in gymnasiums only in emergencies, after disasters. But this Уhad onceФ been a gymnasium, which implies that it was converted to its present use a long time ago. Some major change has taken place, probably not for the good. A УpalimpsestФ was created when a medieval scribe tried to scrape clean a parchment in order to reuse it. Sometimes the scraping process was not complete enough to obliterate all traces of the original text, which could be read faintly underneath the new one. What is suggested by the fact that the immediate supervisors of the girls are women but these women are not allowed guns? What is suggested by the fact that the girls have to read lips to learn each othersТ names?
Section II Shopping
The setting has shifted. It is now much later. What is suggested by the factthat the narrator observes УtheyТve removed anything you could tie a ropeto?Ф Note the play on the proverb УWaste not, want not.Ф What isimplied by the sentence, УNothing takes place in the bed but sleep; or nosleepФ? УLadies in reduced circumstancesФ is a 19th-centuryexpression usually applied to impoverished widows. How does the narrator pun onit? In the gospels, Martha was one of two sisters. She devoted herself tohousework while her sister Mary sat and listened to Jesus. The irony here isthat Jesus praised Mary, not Martha; but the new patriarchy has chosen Martha asthe ideal. What is suggested by the existence of УColoniesФ whereФUnwomenФ live? What are the crimes the MarthaТs gossip about in theirФprivate conversationsФ?
What evidence is there on the second page of this chapter that the revolution which inaugurated this bizarre society is relatively recent? What evidence to reinforce that idea was presented in the opening chapter? Note that Serena Joy bears more than a passing resemblance to Tammy Fay Bakker.
The automobile names are all biblical. Can you guess from the context what an УEyeФ is? УSome of you will fall on dry ground or thorns:Ф see Mark 4:1-9. We will learn eventually that the narratorТs name is УOffred.Ф Her partner is named УOfglen.Ф How do the names of Handmaids seem to be formed? How are we informed that this society (called УGileadФ after a Biblical place name) is under attack? Baptists have a long-standing tradition of local control and individualism. Can you guess at the function of the black-painted vans? What power does Offred have over men, powerless as she is? How traditional is this kind of power? Has the elimination of pornography stopped women from being regarded as sex objects?
What is GileadТs attitude toward higher education? Why is it ominous that the number of widows has diminished. Examine the passage that begins УWomen were not protected then.Ф This is the heart of the ideology that underlies the founding of Gilead. What is its essential rationale? Analyze the narratorТs attitude toward the freedoms of which she speaks. Analyze the play on words in УHabits are hard to break.Ф The clothing store name УLiliesФ is derived from Matthew 6:28. УA land flowing with milk and honeyФ is a common biblical phrase, often used to describe Canaan, the УPromised Land.Ф What is the womenТs reaction to the pregnant woman? УAll fleshФ originally means Уall of humanityФ (see Isaiah 40:5) but here is given a more literal sense as the name for butcher shops. How are the Japanese women different from the women of Gilead? Is Atwood idealizing them? What do you think the point of the contrast is?
What is the function of the Wall? Why have the doctors been executed? The rule that the evidence of one single woman is not adequate is based on Islamic tradition. What is significant about the shift to the present tense in this passage, УLuke wasnТt a doctor. IsnТtФ?
Section III: Night
To what time can Offred travel in her imagination that can be called УgoodФ? The narratorТs pun on Уdate rapeФ depends on the fact that Уrap Ф means УgratedФ or УshreddedФ in French; a date is a fruit, of course. Be careful not to leap to the conclusion that Atwood is mocking the concept of date rape; her attitude is far more complex than that. But why is this reference especially appropriate to the present context? What was the narratorТs reaction as a little girl to her motherТs participation in the burning of pornographic magazines? What relevance does this memory have to her present situation? The next passage is too fragmented to make much sense now, though more context will be provided later. What can you guess about its meaning now? Stories are rarely told in the present tense, as this one is. If a narrator speaks in the past tense, we can be fairly confident that she knows the end of her own story, and that she has survived to tell it. Note how much more open-ended and suspenseful OffredТs narrative is.
Section IV: Waiting Room
What is УGender Treachery?Ф The passage on the etymology of the term УMaydayФ is correct. During World War II, the opening rhythmic pattern from BeethovenТs Fifth Symphony was interpreted as the Morse code for УvФ (dot dot dot dash), and used to symbolize УvictoryФ. What do we learn about OffredТs family in this passage? If a miscarried fetus may or may not be an УUnbabyФ what would an УUnbabyФ seem to be? УAll flesh is grassФ (Isaiah 40:6) is a quotation from the Bible meaning that all humans are mortal. Why does Aunt Lydia use instead the saying Уall flesh is weak?Ф Does she really mean all humans? How about women? How is OffredТs silent correction a reply to her comment? Serena JoyТs speechmaking on behalf of housewifery is a clear satire on the career of Phyllis Shlafley, lawyer, right-wing activist, and cofounder of the Eagle Forum, who put most of her energy for many years into leading the fight against the Equal Rights Amendment while admonishing other women to stay home and raise their children. The Shape of Things to Come is the title of one of H. G. WellТs novels, alluded to ironically at the end of the paragraph beginning УSheТs looking at the tulips.Ф Why does Offred envy Rita her access to the knife? Why is she startled at the end of the chapter when she realizes she has called the room УmineФ?
What feelings does she have as she looks back on the early days of her affair with Luke? Nolite te bastardes carborundorum will be explained in Chapter 29. Note that a posting lasts two years. This will be important later.
Why are the words to the hymn Amazing Grace now considered subversive? Who did Aunt Lydia blame for the УthingsФ that used to happen to women? What sorts of memories does she keep returning to in this chapter?
What do we learn about the Handmaid system during the scene at the doctorТs office? УGive me children, or else I die.Ф (Genesis 30:1). Deuteronomy 17:6 requires that for a couple to be stoned to death on account of adultery there has to be two witnesses to the act.
To what were women vulnerable in bathrooms Уbefore they got all the bugs ironed outФ? For Paul on hair, see 1 Corinthians 11:6-15. What does this mean: УI donТt want to look at something that determines me so completelyФ? The old sexist society was said to reduce women to mere physical objects. Has this changed? What does Offred suggest by saying of the attempted kidnapping of her daughter УI thought it was an isolated incident, at the timeФ? УInheriting the EarthФ: see Matthew 5.5. If Offred was parted from her daughter when she was five and she is eight now, the separation must have happened three years ago. Since at eighteen months the pattern of change was not clear to Offred, the revolution which established Gilead must have been quite recent. It is difficult to believe that such a thorough transformation of society in such a short time, but it is important to remember that this is not a realistic novel, but a satirical dystopia. What associations are aroused by the tattoo on OffredТs ankle? She is remembering scenes from the end of World War II, in which women who dated the Nazi occ upiers had their heads shaved in public. What two meanings of the word УcomposeФ is she playing with in the last paragraph?
Section V: Nap
What do you think about her comments on boredom as erotic? Offred lets herself go back in time to when she was in training with Moira. Does anyone blame women for being raped today? How has OffredТs attitude toward her body changed? What do her dreams about her husband and daughter have in common? What does she mean by saying at the end of the chapter УOf all the dreams this is the worstФ?
Section VI: Household
The mention of a Montreal satellite station reminds us that Atwood is a Canadian, but Montreal is evidently outside of the territory controlled by Gilead. The endless war, always on the brink of victory, is very reminiscent of the war depicted in OrwellТs Nineteen-Eighty-Four. What other locales seem to be on the edge of Gilead? You should be able to gradually construct a rough map of its territory. УThe Children of HamФ is a designation for African-Americans. We are finally told that the narrator is called УOffred,Ф though it isnТt her real name. Why are we never told her real name? Why was the family warned not to look too happy when they are trying to escape Gilead?
Why is the Bible kept locked up? In what era were Bibles routinely sequestered from the general population? Note the series of unflattering phallic images Offred runs over. What is the point of the joke in saying УOne false move and IТm dead.Ф The passages the Commander is reading from the Bible are Genesis 8:17 and 30:1-8. The section beginning УFor lunchФ uses Matthew 5:3-10 (emended) to switch scenes back in time. When we return to the scene in the sitting room, the Commander has just read Genesis 30:18. The scene e nds with Zecharaiah 4:10. Why is this verse chosen as the ritual ending of all Bible readings?
Although this chapter depicts what is clearly the most sensational aspect of Gilead society, it is important not to use it to condemn the novel as Уunrealistic.Ф Refer back to the note on the third epigraph of the novel. Even the perfume has a biblical name, УLily of the Valley,Ф from The Song of Songs 1:2. Why is womenТs pleasure in sex no longer valued?
What is her reaction to NickТs coming to fetch her?
Section VII: Night
What hope keeps Offred alive?
Section VIII: Birth Day
In thinking about the missing cushions, Offred is referring to 1 Corinthians 13: 13. What are the odds that any baby will be seriously deformed? What has caused this situation? The name of Jezebel, the wicked wife of King Ahab, is sometimes used as a label for any shamelessly wicked woman (see 1 Kings 21:1-29). The film shown the women about the former way of giving birth follows the same patt ern as other themes in this novel: ambivalence about feminist reforms. Some women have argued strongly for natural childbirth, but others see this as a step backward. And many positions in between are advocated. Atwood points out that it was modern medicin e that first made pain relief possible during childbirth, though it was at first denounced by preachers who cited the passage quoted at the end of this paragraph, from Genesis 3:16. Anesthetics used during childbirth can be harmful to the infant, but they can also be very beneficial for the mother. This example illustrates well AtwoodТs general approach in this novel: certain radical feminist positions and their opposite conservative positions are both depicted as too extreme. Reality is more complex, she seems to be saying. УAgent OrangeФ was the defoliant widely used on the forests of Vietnam and which was later blamed for numerous biological problems among soldiers.
Birthing stools were once in widespread use and have been reintroduced by women who argue that giving birth in a sitting position is both more natural and more comfortable. Do you know the real source of the quotation, УFrom each according to her ability; to each according to his needsФ? (It has been slightly but significantly altered.) How valid is the use of sadistic porn films by the Aunts to argue against the old society? УTake Back the NightФ originated as the slogan of Women Against Pornography, but has developed in more recent years into an anti-rape slogan. What themes of the womenТs movement is Atwood blending together here? What do you think her attitude toward them is? It may be difficult to imagine now, but in some feminist circles in the seventies a woman who chose to bear a child could come under considerable pressure from other feminists, like OffredТs mother. What are the main tensions between Offred and her mother? These distinctions are part of the crux of the novel, which is about a society which reacted to the older feminists by repression and which the younger women did not sufficiently combat. Why did she rebel against her mother as a young woman? How does she feel about her mother now?
What do we learn in this chapter about how an УUnwomanФ is defined? The reference to a УwomenТs cultureФ at the end of the chapter refers to certain kinds of feminists who have argued that women possess superior values and could build a superior society. What is OffredТs attitude toward this idea?
In what way is Moira a Уloose womanФ?
How does Offr ed try to defend herself against her terror when she first enters the study? Playing scrabble seems like an absurdly trivial form of transgression; why is it significant in this setting? Why does she lie about her reaction when the Commander asks her to ki ss him?
How does Offred interpret Aunt LydiaТs teachings about men? What do you think of this idea? What does the story about the death camp commanderТs mistress convey? In ancient medicine, hysteria was a disease of women, caused by unnatural movements of the womb. How does Offred describe the sound of her beating heart?
Section X: Soul Scrolls
Why does Offred covet Serena JoyТs shears? What do these occasional dark comments tell us about the state of her mind underneath her usual bitterly sarcastic narrative? WomenТs fashion magazines such as the Commander shows Offred were once the target of fierce criticism from feminists. What does she say these magazines offered? How do the pictures of the women impress her? УMy wife doesnТt understand meФ is such an old clich as uttered by men trying to start an affair that it has become a joke.
A British expression says that a pregnant woman has a Уbun in the oven.Ф How have her feelings changed toward the Commander? How have his feelings changed toward her?
Loaves and Fishes refers to a miracle story told in the Gospels (see the accountin Mark 6:34-44). Note how the memory of the ice cream store leads Offred tothoughts of her daughter. The Soul Scroll machines are most obviously likeTibetan prayer wheels, which are turned to activate the prayers inside them; butthey are also reminiscent to the old Catholic practice of paying priests to sayprayers for the repose of the dead. What do Ofglen and Offred see immediatelyafter they have revealed their true views to each other?
Why did Moira criticize Offred for УstealingФ Luke and how did Offreddefend herself? УDiscoth quesФ nightclubs with recorded ratherthan live music originated in France. The name was soon abbreviated toФdisco.Ф The main feature of the book of Job is intense suffering. Whywould a totalitarian dictatorship prefer computer banking to paper money? Notethe statement by the newsstand clerk that sex-oriented enterprises can never begotten rid of entirely. She turns out to be right later. The law prohibiting theownership of property by women reinstates the law as it stood in the 19thcentury and earlier. Many of the extreme aspects of Giladean culture haveactually existed in the past. In the passage which begins УRememberingthis, I remember also my mother,Ф note how anti-porn and abortion riots areblended together, though her mother must have been against porn and forabortion. Her opponents in the abortion demonstrations must have been herallies in the anti-porn demonstrations. Why did Offred find her motherembarrassing when she was an adolescent? How has her attitude changed now? Whywas Offred afraid to ask Luke how he really felt about her losing her job?
УPen Is EnvyФ is of course a pun on FreudТs Уpenis envy,Ф the notion that women who want to be like men are neurotic. When the Commander says of the previous Handmaid who killed herself УSerena found out,Ф what does this mean, and what is OffredТs reaction?
Section XI: Night
There is a traditional Jewish prayer for men which thanks God for not having made them women. This prayer is satirized and parodied in this chapter.
Section XII: JezebelТs
What has changed about the holidays the Fourth of July and Labor Day? Why would Offred like to be able to have a fight with Luke? Taliths are the prayer shawls worn by Jews. УMagen DavidsФ are Stars of David, symbols of Judaism. How do you imagine Serena JoyТs offer of the picture affects Offred? Explain.
УYou canТt make an omelette without breaking eggsФ is a paraphrase of Napoleon justifying the carnage he caused in attempting to build his empire. When a character in fiction uses it, it almost always indicates the speakerТs ruthlessness.
Arranged marriages seem hopelessly exotic to many Americans, but in Western civilization they were the rule rather than the exception until a couple of centuries ago. Evaluate and respond to the arguments that the Commander at the Prayvaganza makes against the old dating and marriage system. The УquotedФ passages which begin УI will that women adorn themselves in modest apparelФ are from 1 Timothy 2:9-15.
React to OffredТs comments on love. In the next to the last paragraph, what does Offred mean when she says she has been УerasedФ?
What is the CommanderТs rationale for the existence of places like JezebelТs? How does he misunderstand when Offred asks him УWho are these people?Ф
УThe Underground FemaleroadФ is of course a pun on the oldФunderground railroadФ along which escaped slaves were smuggled tofreedom. What kind of work do the women in the Colonies do? What does Moira saythe advantages are in working at JezebelТs over being a Handmaid?
Section XIII: Night
Why does Offred feel she has to make up stories about what happened between herself and Nick?
Section XIV: Salvaging
Why does she say on the bottom of page. 268 УI told you it was badФ?
Why are the crimes not described at УSalvagingsФ?
Why does Ofglen attack the УrapistФ so fiercely?
Why does Offred tell her new companion that she met the former Ofglen in May?
УShe has died that I may liveФ is of course a parody of УHe died that we may live,Ф a central Christian doctrine referring to ChristТs crucifixion as a source of salvation for believers.
Section XV: Night
How does Nick reassure Offred when the black van comes? Note the offhanded, ambiguous, but emotionally loaded nature of the last line of OffredТs narrative, typical of her.
Historical Notes on The HandmaidТs Tale
This is the real end of the story, of course, told as a parody of a scholarlysymposium. Note the date, two centuries from now. The title which OffredТsnarrative has been given resembles those of ChaucerТs Canterbury Tales: УThe KnightТs Tale,Ф УThe Wife of BathТs Tale.Ф MostSF dystopias end with a heroic conspiracy or uprising leading to the destructionof the evil government which has oppressed everyone. The jarring shift topretentious scholarly jargon, while amusing to scholars, may be off-putting formost readers; but Atwood is trying to avoid fatalism and sensationalism at thesame time. She is also parodying the ponderous, self-conscious attempts of scholars to be humorous. There is a long tradition of УnowhereФ namesin utopian fiction. УUtopiaФ means УnowhereФ and SamuelButler called his utopia УErewhon.Ф The Chair comes from theUniversity of УdenyФ which is in the country of Уnone ofit.Ф But gturner@Selkirk.bc.ca of Selkirk College comments further on these place names:
The Northwest Territories in Canada as an area has been associatedwith two large native groupsЦthe Dene (read УDenayФ) in the Western Arctic andthe Inuit in the Eastern Arctic. In fact, the Northwest Territories throughreferendum (already held) will be divided into two massive land areas known asDenendeh and Nunavut. УNunavutФ means УOur LandФ to the Inuit.
So itТs quite likely that Atwood meant the University of Denay to becoloured by the Dene and its massive land claims in the 1980s and the huge areato the East of the Mackenzie River Valley known as УNunavut.Ф That she changedthe spelling of УNunavutФ to УNunavitФ is also interesting as УNunaФ stillmeans УlandФ and УvitФ may mean Уto live.Ф
Anthropology has traditionally been carried out by whites onminorities. Here an evidently Native American scholar has as her specialtystudying whites, a deliberately ironic twist. Other names suggest that thisconference is in fact dominated by Native Americans. It is difficult to see howKrishna (the erotic lover in Hindu mythology) and Kali (the also erotic avengingdemon slaying goddess) have to do with Gileadean religion, though that may beAtwoodТs point. Scholars tend to read what they already know into w hat they areless familiar with. Certainly plenty of scholars have analyzed Krishna as aChrist figure. The reference to the УWarsaw TacticФ is more grim: theNazis walled up the Warsaw Jews in the ghetto and proceeded to starve most ofthem to death. The reference to Iran is of course the most pointed, because ofthat nationТs conservative Islamic revolution which involved strenuousdemodernizing and drastic restrictions on the freedom of women. The Iranianexample is one of the main inspirations of this novel. Given what ProfessorPieixoto has to say about the discovery of УThe HandmaidТs Tale,Ф howdrastically would America seem to have changed between the end of the lastchapter and now? Anthropologists are famous for their refusal to judge thesocieties they study. What do you think is AtwoodТs reaction to this strivingfor objectivity in the case of Gilead? How do you feel about it? WilliamWordsworth famously defined poetry as Уemotion recollected intranquillity.Ф Note the allusion. Many details about the Gilead societyТspolicies are revealed here. Atwood takes the opportunity to point to currenttendencies which could lead in the direction depicted in the novel. ThespeakerТs jibe at OffredТs education is not a comment on women, but the smuglysuperior observation of a South American mocking the inadequacies of NorthAmerica, clearly much fallen from its previous dominance. Note the Canadianreferences in this section. УParticicutionФ would seem to be ascholarly term formed out of Уparticipant executionФ to label whatGilead called Уsalvaging.ФFor the scapegoat, see Leviticus 16:10.Prof. PieixotoТs talk is of a type familiar to literary historians: the attemptto connect a the author of a text with some historical person known from otherrecords, particularly in Medieval studies. But for us, the identification isirrelevant, it is the knowledge that Offred survived and the rebellionoriginally triumphed that matters. The final call for questions is traditional,of course, but also serves here as an invitation to further discussion of theissues Atwood has raised.